Happy New Year!
2011 marked an exceptionally productive year for Kinney Recruiting, both in our Domestic and International groups. After deep, recession-fueled cuts to lawyer head counts at most major law firms in 2008 and 2009 (and a cautious 2010), law firm and in-house hiring rebounded in an exciting and pronounced way that only looks to continue in 2012. Internationally, Kinney once again placed the most lawyers in the major Asia markets, including Hong Kong, Singapore, Shanghai and Beijing. To celebrate, in December we embarked on a 10-day off-site meeting in Hong Kong and Macau with all our recruiters. It was a great opportunity to spend time with far-flung colleagues from Russia, Asia and other parts of the U.S. and it allowed us the chance to continue to share best practices and techniques for continued success by all Kinney recruiters.
In the domestic market, we had success “coast to coast,” making placements with firms of all size in markets from New York to the Silicon Valley (and quite a few Texas markets in between . . .). We had the privilege to work with some truly exceptional candidates and to connect them with strong opportunities whether those opportunities were local or across the country.
Korea – The Next Frontier – But When?
A good number of our placements over the last six years have been of Korean-speaking attorneys, most of whom are Korean natives who were educated in the United States after a preliminary legal education in Korea. There are very few UK-trained Korean transactional lawyers interested in practicing in Asia. [If there are any out there we don’t know yet, we hope you will get in touch.]
In the earlier years of our practice involving placement of these lawyers, we had a large contingent of junior to mid-level candidates who had little interest in Korea as a place to lateral to, although some moved to Korea to work in Korea firms, for family reasons, or because it was easier for them to land positions in Korean firms than in US or UK firms. Some of our more senior Korean US associate candidates over the years have been making strategic career moves to Korean law firms, as well as moves there for family reasons.
Many Korean US associates based in US have long realized that if they wanted to work on deals where their Korean cultural and language skills would provide a head start over others, they needed to do this from overseas in Hong Kong or Tokyo (most likely in Hong Kong, where most Korea practices are based). Increasingly, though, the question has changed from, “What firms in Hong Kong or Tokyo have the best Korean practices?” to, “How soon is it going to be possible for my firm to open in Seoul?” In this post we will attempt to describe in very basic detail the legal framework under which firms who wish to be in Korea as soon as possible can be there. We will also discuss the reasons why the expected boom of Korean US associate hiring in Hong Kong and Seoul, at UK and US firms, in 2011 has been thus far beendelayed for 6+ months.
Historical View of Korean Legal Market for Foreign Legal Consultants
By necessity, due to the closed nature of the legal market in Korea, lawyers admitted in the United States have historically had two choices: these attorneys could either be based in other jurisdictions around Asia (Hong Kong and Tokyo predominately) but fly into Seoul on a regular basis for transactions (and Karaoke), or they could move to Korea to work in a Korean law firm as a foreign legal consultant (“FLC’s”). Some of the most well known transactional firms who have employed FLC’s include: Kim & Chang; Bae, Kim & Lee; Lee & Ko; Shin & Kim; Yulchon; Hwang Mok Park; and Kim, Chang & Lee; Lee & Ko (just to name a few of the best known such firms). For years these firms and others like them have held sway over the indigenous Korean legal market. By virtue of their power to block international competition, they have done very well in the hiring market and some of the more senior partners have earned US top-firm money.
Tags: Asia | Hong KongMongolia and then some…
Mongolia. The name itself conjures up images of warrior horse-lords, high-end cashmere, vast expanses of steppe, endless “ceremonial” toasts of vodka and fermented mare’s milk, and the legendary Genghis Khan (who, in my mind’s eye, looks a bit like Jason Momoa in HBO’s Game of Thrones). OK, maybe I’m the only one who thinks of alcohol, luxury dry goods and epic fantasy novels when I hear the word “Mongolia”, but those who know me well know not to expect anything less (or more) of me!
Mongolia boasts history’s largest contiguous empire on earth, which, during the 13th century, stretched from Korea to Eastern Europe, and from Siberia to the Middle East. Factoring in non-contiguous empires such as the British and the Spanish empires, the Mongol empire still stacks up impressively, coming in second overall to the British Empire by a scant 700,000 square kilometers, or an area about the size of Texas. Today, Mongolia is poised for some empire-building of its own. Mongolia is one of the world’s most resource-rich democracies as well as one of its fastest growing economies. Positioned strategically between China and Russia, Mongolia is in an advantageous position to supply raw materials and resources to those two megaconsumer nations.
Mongolia is already attracting the attention of investment funds; just this month, Khan Investment Management launched the Khan Mongolia Equity Fund which was created to capitalize on the growth opportunities in Mongolia and give investors an opportunity to gain exposure to a rapidly growing country which harbors some of the world’s largest coal, copper, gold and uranium deposits. Travis Hamilton, the director of Khan, predicts for Mongolia “to have the fastest growing economy in the world over the next decade”, with growth driven by the nation’s mining sector.
I’ll raise a glass of vodka to that! But you can keep the fermented mare’s milk. More >>
Tags: Asia | Hong KongSTATE OF THE MARKET IN ASIA / HOW TO HANDLE THE INEVITABLE COUNTER OFFER, BOTH FROM FIRM AND CANDIDATE’S PERSPECTVIE
Please check out our daily blog, www.theasiachronicles.com, where we also have a new post today by Alexis Lamb, regarding the rising need for US litigation associates in Asia, among our numerous daily news posts on international biglaw in Asia.
Here we are in the traditional vacation time of July and August, when interview processes can drag out quite a bit. This is especially true in this current still very hot biglaw market in Asia, where busy hiring partners are also juggling 2-week family vacations (sometimes piggy backed around a week or two working from NYC office, making the vacation time seem extended even further).
We feel fortunate at Kinney Asia that we have been able to add two US associate placements this week already – a junior associate placement in Singapore at a top UK firm and a junior associate placement in Hong Kong at a top UK firm’s Korea practice. This continues what has been a spectacular year for Kinney in Asia, with almost 50 US associate placements already this year.
While we expect the US biglaw associate lateral hiring market in HK / China and Singapore to remain very strong during the 2nd half of ’11, we don’t expect the sizzling hiring pace of the 1st half of ’11 to continue. The first half of ’11 was an anomaly, a situation caused by combination of extreme boom market for more than a year in HK / China and most of Asia, and the odd circumstance of busy Asia offices becoming very understaffed and not being allowed to hire as needed, and for many months not at all, for a 18 months of a bona-fide boom time. The boom has continued since then, another 7 months so far, although deal flow has been slowing a bit in some biglaw firms’ US practices in HK / China (some IPOs in HK, most notably Prada, has fallen flat and investigations and shareholder class actions filed against some Chinese companies have slowed down IPOs of Chinese companies in the US). It is still a very hot market, but going through a speed bump now and there has been a lot of hiring in the past few months.
Tags: Asia | Hong KongIT’S MAY, AND THE LITIGATION OPPORTUNITIES IN ASIA ARE GROWING
Alexis Lamb here, enjoying a balmy spring morning in Hong Kong. Late spring is a mighty fine time to be in Hong Kong and May is one splendid month to be sitting on a junk in the middle of the South China Sea with 30 of your closest friends and a seabreeze in hand. Fortunately for all you Asia-minded US litigators, the number of boats in the harbor isn’t the only thing that’s increasing as the temperatures rise. Litigation opportunities in Hong Kong for US-qualified attorneys have tripled since last fall! Want a piece of the action? Read below…
WHAT KIND OF LITIGATION CAN A U.S. LAWYER DO IN ASIA?
The most “popular” forms of litigation are commercial litigation, arbitration, internal investigations, and civil and criminal government investigations, particularly FCPA litigations. However, an attorney need not have experience in FCPA/white collar investigations to land out here. The hiring partners are adamant that any litigation experience fits the bill and they are more than happy to “retool” an associate to the specific kinds of litigation that their office focuses on.
WHAT SKILLS DO I NEED TO LAND IN ASIA?
Successful applicants will have the three following traits, in order of importance. (1) Business fluency in Mandarin, (2) litigation experience gleaned in a top “biglaw” or elite litigation boutique environment and (3) top grades from a top law school (JD preferred). As a rough benchmark on point 3, I’d say that if you graduated with honors/top 25% from a top 20 law school you’re competitive. Mandarin fluency is the most important criterion. Firms won’t even interview applicants who were top 1% in their top 10 law school classes and had spot-on-point litigation experience because they were English-only. No matter how awesome you are, your resume will not even be looked at if you do not speak business level Mandarin.
Why are firms so strict on the language requirement? Part of the job out in Asia is conducting witness interviews, depositions, and other fact-finding operations in an Asian language, often Mandarin. If you have this experience, you will be a very competitive candidate so put it on your resume! One hiring partner told me that Mandarin is used nearly every day on cases – not just in casual conversation. It’s not enough to be able to shoot the breeze for 5 minutes with clients before a meeting. Your Mandarin must be good enough to pick up nuance in a witness interview or deposition, or translate diligence documents.
Tags: Asia | Hong KongKinney’s 26 (so far) 2011 Asia Placements of US associates in Law Firms
Robert here. It has been a solid past few months for us in HK / China and Singapore. Here is a list of our very recent placements in 2011. We also are in the process now of making numerous additional Asia placements (outstanding offers with our candidate likely to accept). Further, please note that this list does not include the several in-house and partner level placements we have made in Asia this year. We also have represented numerous associates who had offers but transferred within their own firms to Asia. Even these situations are successes when they allow our candidates to make an informed decision.
* – denotes 2 or more 2011 placements in the office
Skadden – Hong Kong *
Milbank – Singapore
Davis Polk – Hong Kong
Latham – Beijing
Latham – Hong Kong
Latham – Singapore
Paul Hastings – Hong Kong *
Simpson Thacher – Hong Kong
Ropes & Gray – Hong Kong
Ropes & Gray – Shanghai (soon to be opened office)
Orrick – Hong Kong
Orrick – Beijing
Clifford Chance – Singapore
Clifford Chance – Hong Kong
A&O – Hong Kong
Proskauer Rose – Hong Kong
Baker & McKenzie – Hong Kong *
Freshfields – Hong Kong
Shearman – Hong Kong
White & Case – Singapore
Linklaters – Singapore
O’Melveny – Shanghai
Skadden – Singapore
Many of the placements listed above represent great launching pad opportunities for our candidates and many did not happen quickly or without great effort on our part. We don’t simply email resumes to a list of firms and hope for the best, as do many so-called recruiters. Our placements are in most cases the result of informing the candidate on their target market for months before they begin a job search and our traveling back and forth between Asia markets and US markets in order to meet with both US associate candidates and partners at their target firms.
Tags: Asia | Hong KongNeed Proof Hong Kong / China is Booming? Try Renting a New Flat!
Alexis Lamb here, writing from my soon-to-be-old flat (err, apartment) in Hong Kong. Housing markets tend to be a barometer of more general market conditions, and nowhere is that more apparent than in more emerging economies. While China is more of an emerging superpower than an emerging economy, the grand fall and rise of the Hong Kong property markets are evidence of general economic strength and renewed optimism in this part of the world.
I moved into my current flat in April 2009, smack-dab in the depths of the economic dead zone. I was able to secure my 680 square-foot, high-floor, doorman building with pool and clubhouse for approximately US$1980 (HK$15,000) without the landlord putting up much of a fuss. If anything, the landlord seemed relieved that someone – anyone – was renting his flat!
Fast forward 2 years to mid-March 2011. Landlord decides to nearly double my rent to HK$25,000, or US$3,200! Before I launched into “Why you gotta break my balls”, I did some market research and found that other flats in my building on similar floors were being rented out for a similar price. Time to get a better deal.
Tags: Asia | Hong KongAs Predicted, The HK / China Mini Hiring Boom Has Begun
Robert here. As we have been predicted would happen in past posts, a sizzling biglaw US associate lateral hiring boom has arrived in Hong Kong / China for the first quarter ’11. We expect this hiring boom to continue until spring, with hiring being steady afterwards but dropping to more normal levels.
A “perfect storm” has developed, causing many US and UK firms in Hong Kong / China to have multiple US corporate / cap markets urgent openings at one time now.
A lot of these top firms in Hong Kong / China have been understaffed since late 2009. When the global recession went into full swing in late 2008, the downturn had started to seriously affect biglaw deal flow in China (about a year after negative effects were felt in US and other Western markets), with IPOs coming to a stop. There was misguided concern at the time that because China had some dependence on US exports for its economy to be fully fueled, China would be heading into a bubble-busting down turn, even much worse than what was taking place in the US. However, in mid-’09, deal flow in China was booming again, fueled in large part by China’s own consumer economy expanding rapidly. This was no surprise to many of us who have observed China for several years. After all, 2009 was the year that China over took the US in new cars purchased annually, China overtook India in gold purchased annually, and the Asia Pacific Region overtook North America in daily commercial flights.
But much of the world was skeptical the boom could continue more than a short time (dramatic bubble-busting predictions sold newspapers and perhaps made some Westerners feel better about themselves) and thus senior firm management at many firms were reluctant to invest heavily with new hires in China, especially considering the recession in West. With the worst recession of our lifetime in full swing, most US firms were on a global hiring freeze and trying to avoid more layoffs, rather than trying to hire laterals for China. The feeling was also that if there was a need to staff up on some deals in China, it could be done by sending over associates not busy in US, at least temporarily, which was a band-aid on what was becoming an understaffing problem. Further, it was just bad internal politics back them for a partner at a US firm in Asia or elsewhere to try to pressure their management for lateral hires because of the big push in ’09 to keep down costs and try to salvage profit numbers (to help recruit and retain partners) in the midst of a major recession.
Tags: Asia | Hong KongBe Careful With Cold-Callers
Robert here. If you are a transactional associate at a top US firm and your name happens to be of Asian origin, especially of Chinese background, then you are probably receiving multiple cold calls per day from recruiters. After all the Asia lateral biglaw markets, especially HK / China are red hot now and it is of course very easy to compile a list of top US firm associates with Asian names.
Keep in mind that there can be very negative consequences in giving control of such an important career move and job search to someone calling you out of the blue (no matter how many times they may call). We often get calls from very well qualified US associates with sad tales of at worst their resume being plastered unauthorized all over China or other Asia markets; or at best only authorized submissions (thankfully) but realizing their recruiter has done little more than emailing their resume to begin with and is unresponsive for weeks.
It is important to note that your resume is a very valuable commodity to recruiters calling you. When you are placed at a law firm, the recruiter who submitted your resume is typically paid (by the law firm) 25 to 30% of your starting base salary. Thus, the recruiters cold-calling you have a big incentive to get a hold of your resume and email it to law firms, with or without your authorization (believe it or not, some biglaw recruiters in Asia are known to be even less ethical than the worst of the lot in the US). Once your resume has been submitted to a law firm, the recruiter who did so “owns” your candidacy there for at least six months. Further, when your resume has been submitted without your authorization, it will take an affidavit from you to the target firm explaining such for the submission to be reversed (and basically that is you explaining to the firm that you did not know you even applied there, which can of course cool off any motivation of that firm to continue to want to interview you, and the unethical recruiter is counting on you to thus not take that route).
We try to think that a lot of recruiters do not take such unethical steps, but please note that even the most well-intentioned recruiters trying to break into the Asia markets are more often than not woefully inexperienced with such lateral placements (and even most of those with some experience have never been more than resume pushers).
Tags: Asia | Hong Kong